Home of the FREE weekly email Update

Home Reviews News
Contact Potomac Stages About Potomac Stages
 
 
Web PotomacStages

Curtains
 

Al Hirschfeld Theatre
302 West 45th Street
New York
Reviewed by Brad Hathaway

Reviewed March, 2007
Running time 2:35 - one intermission
Price range $61 - $111
A fun and funny musical whodunit
Click here to read our review of the CD


A big back-stage musical, more in the mold of Kiss Me Kate than Kiss of the Spider Woman, confirms the genius of the song writing team of John Kander and Fred Ebb. Not that any confirmation would be needed after Cabaret, Chicago, and a host of others, not to mention the previously mentioned Kiss of the Spider Woman. There are songs such as "Show People," a paean to show business itself in the tradition of "There's No Business Like Show Business." There is an openly sarcastic view of the flip side of the coin, "Its A Business," an elegant dance sequence called "A Tough Act to Follow" and a touching tribute to the collaborative art of musical theater making, "I Miss The Music." The entire score is a delight in service of an intriguing whodunit with twists and turns aplenty. The show has a collection of well drawn character parts for a sterling collection of well known Broadway performers, and a starring role for David Hyde Pierce that he uses to deliver a performance that is likely to, at a minimum, give him a Tony Award nomination.


Storyline: The cast and creative team of a musical having its pre-Broadway tryout in Boston in 1959 are rocked by the murder of the star of the show during the curtain call on opening night. The police detective assigned to investigate is a died-in-the-wool theater fan who is honored to meet everyone involved, but who must also suspect everyone who was on stage at the time. In the course of his investigation, other members of the company are murdered as well. The detective not only solves the crime, he makes suggestions to solve the problems of the musical and wins the love of his favorite member of the cast.

It has been a long time since a project that seemed to be so jinxed early on has come to such a delightful conclusion. This bright, tuneful, laugh filled and thoroughly enjoyable evening started as a concept in the mind of Peter Stone - but he died. Rupert Holmes picked it up and now a solidly satisfying structure serves the show well. The score, including a few certified crowd pleasers, came from Kander and Ebb - but Fred Ebb died. Kander carried on. He and Holmes added lyrics where necessary, without, they say, doing much to change those that Ebb himself penned before his death in 2004. Enough talk of death! Lets talk about the show. What a series of delights!

Pierce accomplishes the feat of making all three aspects of his character's personality believable. His detective work is no bumbling Inspector Jacques Clouseau in search of a Pink Panther, although he's not exactly Sherlock Holmes either. There's enough competence in his detecting to keep that side of the character from ridicule, just as there is in his portrayal of the stage-struck fan. That's important, for no fawning dolt could win the hand and heart of the girl of his dreams. Pierce finds the basic intelligence and decency in the character, and that keeps the show from turning sour. Everyone in the company is a version of one or another stock character from theater lore, but each is given an affectionate portrayal by a familiar Broadway face. The money-grubbing producer is a show-stopping Debra Monk. The egomaniacal director is a crowd-pleasing Edward Hibbert, who gets many of the funniest lines in the show. The self-important theatre critic is played straight by John Bolton. (As the marvelous first act song asks: "What kind of man would take a job like that?") The innocent ingénue is the lovely and graceful Jill Paice. The star turned songwriter who is forced back into performing is the ever impressive Karen Ziemba, and she's paired with Jason Danieley, who, as her song writing collaborator, is at his best delivering the song "I Miss The Music" which is given even more poignancy for its resonance in this first Kander and Ebb show after the death of Fred Ebb.

Director Scott Ellis keeps his cast from making the mistake of turning this fast-paced musical comedy into some sort of solemn tribute to Ebb and Stone. Instead, the production breathes life into the creation of Stone, Kander and Ebb, and delivers the kind of entertaining evening they and their collaborators had in mind. Powerful, big-band musical arrangements by William David Brohn support the songs, and there are really nifty dance arrangements by David Chase for Rob Ashford's clever choreography which nod in the direction of Michael Kidd one moment and Hermes Pan the next. Musical director and conductor David Loud gets into the act and even has a cameo of his own.

Music by John Kander. Lyrics by Fred Ebb. Book by Rupert Holmes. Original book and concept by Peter Stone. Additional lyrics by John Kander and Rupert Holmes. Directed by Scott Ellis. Choreographed by Rob Ashford. Musical direction and vocal arrangements by David Loud. Orchestrations by William David Brohn. Dance arrangements by David Chase. Design: Anna Louizos (set) William Ivey Long (costumes) Paul Huntley (hair and wigs) Angelina Avallone (make up) Rick Sordelet (fight direction) Paul Rubin (aerial effects) Peter Kaczorowski (lights) Brian Ronan (sound.) Cast: Nili Bassman, Kevin Bernard, Ward Billeisen, John Bolton, Paula Leggett Chase, Jason Danieley, Jennifer Dunne, Matt Farnsworth, Patty Goble, Edward Hibbert, Mary Ann Lamb, David Loud, Brittany Marcin, Michael X. Martin, Michael McCormick, Debra Monk, Jim Newman, Jill Paice, David Hyde Pierce, Noah Racey, Joe Aaron Reid,  Darcie Roberts, Ernie Sabella, Megan Sikora, Christopher Spaulding, Karen Ziemba.