Home of the FREE weekly email Update

Home Reviews News
Contact Potomac Stages About Potomac Stages
 
 
Web PotomacStages

 
Jersey Boys
 

August Wilson Theatre
245 West 52nd Street
New York
Reviewed by Brad Hathaway

Reviewed July, 2007
Running time 2:30 - one intermission
Price range $96 - $121
A great book musical with a jukebox score delivered superbly
Click here to read our review of the CD

Click here to buy the CD


The Tony Award voters got it right when they named this, the first dramatically solid jukebox bio-musical, the best musical of the year. The year was the 2005-06 season. That was not a particularly stellar twelve months for Broadway, but this show is so well constructed, staged and performed that it would have held its own in a much stronger season. Simply put, the show delivers a theatrically induced high that lasts long after the show has ended. That is because not only are the vocal performances superb, they are matched by dramatic performances of equal quality and both are delivered in service to a book that tells its story so clearly and with such empathy that it carries the audience along for a dramatic ride as well as a journey down popular music memory lane. Now, as the show approaches its second anniversary, it feels as fresh and affective as a brand new hot ticket hit.


Storyline:
The history of Frankie Valli and the Four Seasons is presented through a blend of the memories of those who lived it including lead vocalist Valli, song writer and group member Bob Gaudio and group member Tommy DeVito. The story is punctuated with performances of over thirty of the group's songs from best sellers like "Sherry" and "Can't Take My Eyes Off Of You" to songs early in their career where they were just the back up group to other lead singers.

There have been many attempts in recent years to use the catalogue of an established star or group as the score of a Broadway musical. After all - the common wisdom goes - people already know and presumably love the music, so half the battle of creating a successful musical should already be won. Would that it were that simple! Some have tried to append the catalogue to a story unrelated to the singer or songwriters who made the songs popular in the first place. That worked for Mamma Mia! but that confection of a musical was the exception to the rule of failure that gave us the likes of Good Vibrations (the Beach Boys) and All Shook Up (Elvis). Others have found success in something akin to the revue format with Smokey Joe's Cafe (the hits of songwriters Leiber and Stoller) but more often the effort seems ill fated as in Ring of Fire (Johnny Cash) or even musicals with the name of the star/subject like Lennon. None, however, found the secret of a biographical piece of solid dramatic structure punctuated with the infectious music of the subject - until now.

Neither Marshall Brickman nor Rick Elice had ever written the book for a Broadway musical before they teamed up to do Jersey Boys. Brickman had been head writer for Johnny Carson's Tonight Show. Elice had been creative director of a Broadway PR firm. Somehow, they found the key. It was drama. Jersey Boys may use all the tools of pop and pizzazz, but the show does so to tell a compelling, dramatically satisfying story. That may sound simple, but think of the thousands of non-musicals that set out to tell a compelling, dramatically satisfying story and how few of them succeed. Add the complexity of using pre-existing songs with lyrics written with anything but autobiography in mind. Then consider the challenge of casting.

For the main narrator and group founder Tommy DeVito, the producers came up with Christian Hoff, who had been a pinball boy in The Who's Tommy for director Des McAnuff a decade ago, and has toured the nation in musicals for most of the time since. He brings a confidence based on that experience to the stage which supports the decision of the Tony voters to name him best supporting actor in a musical. They also came up with a talented and impressive cast for all the other roles as well. But none was as impressive as a young man by the name of John Lloyd Young who had never appeared on a Broadway stage and who wasn't a singer. He takes the role of Frankie Valli from innocent youngster with a strange falsetto to mature professional with complete believability and dramatic intensity, while also delivering the signature sound of the Four Seasons with magnetic force. No wonder he took home the Tony Award for best lead actor in a musical! (He performs six evening performances a week.)

Music by Bob Gaudio. Lyrics by Bob Crewe. Book by Marshall Brickman and Rick Elice. Directed by Des McAnuff. Choreographed by Sergio Trujillo. Music direction, vocal arrangements and incidental music by Ron Melrose. Orchestrations by Steve Orich. Fight direction by Steve Rankin. Design: Klara Zieglerova (set) Jess Goldstein (costumes) Charles LaPointe (wigs and hair) Michael Clark (projections) Howell Binkley (lights) Steve Canyon Kennedy (sound). Principal cast: Peter Gregus, Christian Hoff, Mark Lotito, Daniel Reichard, J. Robert Spencer, John Lloyd Young or Michael Longoria.